September 2, 2012

Dictators spurn their nations’ health care

Filed under: Ethiopia,Meles Zenawi — ethiopiantimes @ 1:42 pm
Tags: , ,
Updated 4:28 p.m., Saturday, September 1, 2012
  • Ethiopians from a community of people with disabilities arrive Aug. 25 to pay their respects in Addis Ababa at the coffin of Prime Minister Meles Zenawi, who died days earlier at a hospital in Belgium. Though their citizens are stuck with their nations' meager health services, dictators often travel abroad for better care. Photo: Rebecca Blackwell, Associated Press / SF
    Ethiopians from a community of people with disabilities arrive Aug. 25 to pay their respects in Addis Ababa at the coffin of Prime Minister Meles Zenawi, who died days earlier at a hospital in Belgium. Though their citizens are stuck with their nations’ meager health services, dictators often travel abroad for better care. Photo: Rebecca Blackwell, Associated Press / SF


Meles Zenawi, Ethiopia’s dictator, died last month – in a Brussels hospital.

Why didn’t he get medical care at home? Look at the state of his people’s health, and you’ll understand.

The government provides vaccinations for only 5 percent of the children. Fewer still receive antibiotics when they contract pneumonia. Only 20 percent of teenage girls are educated about AIDS. Is it any wonder that Ethiopia’s average life expectancy is 56 – among the world’s lowest?

Eleven years ago, 53 African nations signed a pledge to spend at least 15 percent of their national budgets on health care. Almost no nation has lived up to that. Right now, Ethiopia dedicates 3.6 percent of its budget to health. So no one was surprised when the president went abroad for care.

In fact, across the developing world, whenever a president or potentate gets sick, he travels to a more developed state for care. That boldly displays the heedless view these leaders have of their own people. Perhaps if they were required to use their own hospitals, they might be more inclined to improve them.

Many of these reprobates find they can’t step on the plane as blithely as Zenawi did. To get away often requires stealth and deceit.

Not long ago, Asif Ali Zardari, Pakistan’s president, wanted to go abroad for an unspecified, apparently minor health issue. So he directed doctors at a Karachi hospital to forge a report saying he had a more significant illness: prostate cancer. Dr. Ghayur Ayub, a former national director general of health, had a look at the lab results and on his blog declared the diagnosis “ludicrous.” Zardari left anyway.

Last year, he decided to spend some time in Dubai. His spokesmen said he’d gone to visit his children. But that was proved to be a lie after he entered a hospital. The rambunctious Pakistani press declared that he was being treated for a host of different problems: a heart attack, a clot in his neck, a dangerous reaction to medicine.

After he’d been away two weeks, the news media began writing about the political message Zardari was sending. Pulse International, Pakistan’s most prominent medical journal, wrote that Zardari’s trip demonstrated a “lack of trust and confidence in Pakistani healthcare professionals and healthcare institutions.” It turned out he’d had a minor stroke.

Zardari is hardly alone. Since Hugo Chavez, the Venezuelan strongman, took office in 1999, he has bragged ceaselessly about improving health care for his people. But when he contracted cancer, he flew off to Cuba – twice. That’s a telling statement about Venezuelan medicine. Cuban doctors say they earn about $24 a month.

In Venezuela, rumors are rife that Chavez’s cancer is terminal, though he denies that. Is he lying? You decide. Chavez suddenly decided to build a $140 million mausoleum for Simon Bolivar, the 19th century political and military leader Chavez reveres. The Venezuelan press notes that the building has room for at least one more resident.

Hun Sen, Cambodia’s prime minister, visited constituents a while back and noted that he had a minor wound needing treatment. He insisted that only when “doctors in Cambodia say they cannot deal with it will I go to a hospital abroad.” He failed to note that a few years earlier he had traveled to Tokyo for what the government said was a two-day “checkup.” Cambodian doctors aren’t capable of even that? Like the other leaders who travel abroad, health and welfare conditions in his country are no better than those in Ethiopia.

But in Saudi Arabia, an exceedingly wealthy state, Prince Nayef said he was traveling abroad for “medical tests” last spring. He was gone a month and said he’d been in a Cleveland hospital but provided no other details. He died in June – in a Geneva hospital.

Dictators always seem to be traveling abroad for simple tests or checkups. Nursultan Nazarbayev, Kazakhstan’s president, insisted he was in a German hospital for a “checkup” last year – though he had issued a press release saying, “I suggest everyone have routine checkups here in Kazakhstan.” A German paper reported that he was treated for prostate cancer.

This spring, a South African newspaper reported that government leaders from Malawi, Gabon, Togo, Nigeria and Tanzania all had died in foreign hospitals. The paper then made a note of a fact that every one of those leaders’ constituents ought to stand up and shout about: These heads of state “prefer to pour taxpayers’ money into overseas medical facilities rather than spending it on improving health care at home.”

Joel Brinkley, a professor of journalism at Stanford University, is a Pulitzer Prize-winning former foreign correspondent for the New York Times. Send your feedback to us through our online form at © 2012 Joel Brinkley

Read more:



  1. Meles Zenawi was a junkie who lost his life by overdosing to prescription medications.

    He went out of the hospital in Belgium early saying he will move to a hospital in Ethiopia but remained in hiding in Belgium taking unauthorized medications which he overdosed and died from.

    Comment by Wuhib — September 3, 2012 @ 2:03 am | Reply

  2. .Don’t ask a stupid question? Why leaders of every country get special care? Why they don’t walk by foot? Why like every homeless sleep on the street? Pm was very important person, he and a person like him must get the best health care and best security on earth because those elite people can build the best of anything in their country. Every country in the world keeps their elites in a good care unless anarchists’ get a chance to brain washed the people for the distraction. Ethiopian people enemies wish all good visionaries of the country to die to get what they want. Those disabled people getting a care because someone cared. We knew before all those kinds of people were bagging on side of the road with their wounds in day time and sleep on the street at night. Those disabled peoples are witnessing, who they lost? Gold is helpful at the time of hard ship. Pm Meles Zenawi was a diamond for the people and the country, have no doubt about him to build a better hospital with the best doctors than the one he get help. Stupid start saying am TPLF, you moron. Do something to help the growth of economy if you have a better idea, that is a better move.

    Comment by Solomon Getachew — September 8, 2012 @ 7:29 pm | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: